New court guidelines aim to tackle rise in allegations of alienating behaviours
Judicial concern at the rise in allegations of alienating behaviours during family proceedings in the North has prompted the introduction of new guidance on the matter.
Issued by the Lady Chief Justice the Family Proceedings - Allegations of Alienating Behaviour guidance came into effect on October 13, 2026 and applies to family proceedings in all court tiers.
It has been welcomed by Derry-based family systems and separation consultant, Donna-Maria Bradley.
Speaking to The Derry News, Ms Bradley explained alienating behaviours could be “subtle, overt or develop gradually over time”.
“They can include anything from badmouthing, denigrating, degrading, undermining, discrediting or portraying the other parent negatively,” said Ms Bradley.
“It can also include interference with communication or contact plans and placing unnecessary emotional pressure on a child to distance themselves from a parent and other family members - grandparents, uncles, aunts, cousins,” she added.
“I believe this guidance is a really important development in the area of family law which has become increasingly complex and, in my opinion, highly polarised at times.
“For families experiencing family separation, if that involves coercive control, alienating behaviours, it is ultimately the children that are impacted by this.
“And the consequences they have to deal with when they are involved in these family dynamics can cause considerable trauma that doesn’t just affect them while going through the separation.
Think about Christmas. It’s a really stressful time which brings a lot of financial pressures and different things but imagine waking up on Christmas morning knowing that you are not getting to see your child, and you have no control over that.
“We have to look at what they were experiencing before the separation, before they started to resist and refuse contact, because when family dynamics become fractured, there might be multiple reasons why a child starts to resist and refuse contact,” said Ms Bradley,
“And those reasons might be justified, for instance where a parent has a confirmed history of domestic abuse or another safeguarding red flag,” she added, “and these have to be considered from the beginning of family proceedings.
“When a child voices their refusal of contact, you have to determine the basis, the family background and, if there has been a confirmed history of domestic abuse, then that child is potentially estranged.
“There may be anxiety and other issues going on and It is not a case that they are being alienated.
“Parents who have been alienated must have no history of any safeguarding concerns for it to be considered. This is one of the areas where there is a lot of misinformation, and they need to be separated.
“This is one of the reasons I am calling for professionals, not just in the legal system, all professionals who are dealing and working with families every day, to be able to identify specifically what constitutes alienating behaviour. They also need to have an understanding of what is not considered an outcome of parental alienation because there are significant differences between the two,” said Ms Bradley.
Ms Bradley said she was worried about families being referred for “court-appointed expert reports” during family proceedings.
“In my opinion, single expert reports are not the way forward,” she cautioned. “I am not criticising court experts in any way. I understand they are extremely under-resourced.
“But the statutory services, the child protection, the safeguarding services involved, if they are not trained and equipped to identify allegations of alienating behaviours, there is a possibility children are going to be overlooked and could potentially be living in homes where they are being subjected to these behaviours.”
Ms Bradley stressed the importance of listening to the “voice of the child” if a child starts to express resistance and refusal to contact.
“We have to examine what is behind that expression. What are the family dynamics? Are there any substantiated claims? If there are no substantiated claims, no present history of confirmed safeguarding concerns, then we have to look at whether there is a presence of alienating behaviour,” she said.
“Is the child being prevented from seeing other family members, not just dad or mum but grandparents, aunts, uncles, other siblings, because siblings can get caught up in this too, and that’s another divide,” added Ms Bradley.
“Think about Christmas. It’s a really stressful time which brings a lot of financial pressures and different things but imagine waking up on Christmas morning knowing that you are not getting to see your child, and you have no control over that.
“But imagine the wee child and they are thinking about their mum or dad but they can’t say they miss them. They are just obeying. They are silenced because they have learned that if I speak out about my mum or dad, it may upset the other parent, so they suppress everything they are feeling and they are carrying.”
Ms Bradley was adamant this can have a “significant” effect on a child in later life.
“It is a loss of their identity. Say they have lost a relationship with their dad, and dad might have been one that took them out on cycles on their bike, or taught them to fix a puncture, or out to the garage, the child has lost all those life skills,” she said.
“They have also lost relationships with grandparents and other family members.
“Someone recently said to me, say your daughter is out in the park and she lifts a wee feather or a wee daisy and says how much she loves you, it’s the loss of all those wee moments.
“But it is not just the parent’s time. This is the child’s time. This is the child’s life that has been affected.
“People need to wake up because this is not one parent against the other, this is a family system issue and people have to work together.”