Derry couple jailed for £144,000 benefit fraud lose appeal brought before the Supreme Court in Belfast

placeholder image

A Derry couple jailed for benefit fraud in 2013 have lost an appeal brought before the Supreme Court in Belfast.

In 2013, Michael Cecil Harkin, then aged 50, and Donna McCool, then aged 46, both of Circular Road in the city, were jailed for eight and four months respectively.

They admitted a combined total of 11 income support, jobseeker's allowance and housing benefits frauds spanning a 20-year period starting in 1990.

McCool's total fraud amounted to £76,800 and Harkin's totalled £67,300.

A prosecution barrister told the court that both defendants made false declarations about their marital status in order to unlawfully claim the benefits.

In 2014, Derry Crown Court (above) approved a Confiscation Order to the value of £38,814 for the Social Security Agency Financial Investigation Unit against each of them.

The couple had appealed against the confiscation orders, which was heard before the Supreme Court which was sitting in Belfast for the first time this week.

However, the appeal was dismissed by the Supreme Court by a majority of three to two.

Commenting, Jack Quigley of Madden & Finucane, Solicitor for both Appellants, stated that despite losing their appear, the couple had been ‘vindicated’ in bringing the appeal.

“Mr Harkin and Mrs McCool were today vindicated in bringing their appeals to the highest domestic Court available to them,” he said.

“The Appellants convinced both Lord Mance and Lord Reed that the Confiscation Orders made against them at Derry Crown Court were unlawful.

“We shall take time to consider the implications of today's majority decision from the five Law Lords and consider whether there is merit in an application to the European Court of Human Rights.”

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice