Defendant, who was stabbed in the head with scissors, bit the other man’s ear off

placeholder image

By Garrett Hargan

A man and woman have appeared at Derry Magistrate’s Court charged with offences arising from a fight, in a case involving counter allegations.

Harry Boyle, 27, of Galliagh Park, has been charged with causing grievous bodily harm with intent to a male on January 27.

In relation to the same incident, Ursula Logue, 33, of Carnhill, has been charged with wounding Boyle with intent to do him GBH.

Appearing in court, a police officer said that at 1.49pm on the date in question, Boyle reported that he had been stabbed by Logue or a Mr Francis McShane – who is currently being questioned by police.  The PSNI attended Boyle’s address along with the ambulance service and he told them he had been ‘stabbed on the top of the head with scissors’.

The 27-year-old had gone to the flat to ‘collect money’ from McShane when a verbal argument was followed by a physical confrontation in the hallway.  He claimed he was ‘punched about the head’ and that Logue ‘had scissors’ that were used to stab him in the head.  Boyle left and went to his address where he contacted police.

‘Completely severed’

At 2.23pm McShane reported that Boyle ‘had bitten his ear off’.  Police attended McShane’s Carnhill address where they noted a ‘severe injury’ to his ‘left ear’.  It was said to have been ‘completely severed’ and he was take to Altnagelvin Hospital for treatment.  Surgery was carried out on Sunday, January 28, but it was ‘unable to be reattached’.

Boyle was arrested in the hospital on the Saturday after McShane had provided his account.  The 27-year-old was not fit to be interviewed until Sunday when he made ‘full admissions from the outset’.  He said he called to McShane’s flat where Logue was present ‘to get money he owed’ – which police believe to be linked to drugs supply - and they ended up on the floor after an argument.

The 27-year-old alleges that while they were on the ground McShane shouted, ‘grab a knife’, a police officer explained.  She said Boyle saw a coloured pair of scissors but due to being in a confined space he was ‘unable to say who caused the injury’.  Then, ‘in a state of panic, he bit down but didn’t know what he bit down on.’  McShane then got off him and he left.

Objecting to bail in the case of Boyle, a police officer said it was a serious offence, there is a risk of interference with witnesses as he knows where McShane lives, and a risk of reoffending as Boyle is a man with eighteen previous convictions.

The alleged offence was also committed while he was on bail and he was in breach of his conditions by taking drugs.

Representing Boyle, defence solicitor Seamus Quigley said Logue has been charged and McShane is in police custody accused of attacking Boyle.  He told the court that Boyle was ‘blocked’ from leaving the property and ‘then attacked from behind by McShane’.

Mr Quigley said the 27-year-old says ‘he was strangled’ and heard someone shouting ‘get the knife’ before he was stabbed in the head.  Whilst ‘all of these things were happening’, he then bit down not knowing what he was biting on in a ‘defensive manoeuvre’.

Punishment shooting

The court was told that Boyle was diagnosed with Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) after he was subjected to a ‘horrific punishment shooting’ two years ago, which left him with ‘life-changing injuries to his leg’.  As a consequence, he is now prescribed an ‘extreme amount’ of pain medication, Mr Quigley explained.  He added, the incident ‘essentially brought everything back’ so he ‘completely panicked and bit down’.

It was submitted that Boyle didn’t realise the extent of the injury he caused, and the defence solicitor asked for him to be granted bail to his home address.

Deputy District Judge Rea granted Boyle his own bail of £500, he is excluded from entering Carnhill, have no contact with the injured party or witnesses and must comply with the directions of the community addiction team.  He will appear at a court sitting on March 2.

Detailing Logue’s involvement in the incident, a police officer said the 33-year-old was staying overnight at McShane’s house when Boyle came around the next day.  She let him in and soon thereafter heard an argument between the two men which she tried to break up.

Denies Stabbing

Boyle then got up and left, and it was only then she noticed the injury to McShane.  Logue denies stabbing Boyle and ‘doesn’t know how he came about his injury’.  Police objected to bail for the same reasons as Boyle, and raised concerns about the proposed bail address at her mother’s in Rosemount Gardens.  The officer said Logue has a drug addiction and did not believe it was appropriate for her to reside with her three children - who stay at the mother’s address.

Paddy MacDermott, defending, said his client ‘totally denies having stabbed’ Boyle and she ‘has nothing for violence on her record’ aside from one assault on police.  He explained that she takes prescription medication for anxiety and suggested her mother’s address could provide a ‘degree of comfort’ to her.

After requesting that Logue’s mother take to the witness box to provide assurances, Judge Rea granted the 33-year-old her own bail of £500 to reside at Rosemount Gardens.  She has similar conditions to Boyle and will appear at a Magistrate’s Court sitting on February 22.

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice