Derry man jailed for two years after Donegal hotel assault on stag party

Sentencing hearing occurred at Letterkenny Courthouseplaceholder image
Sentencing hearing occurred at Letterkenny Courthouse | Iconic

Judge rules defendant’s fists were weapons in Bridgend assault that left victim fearing for his life.

A Derry man who “went absolutely crazy” has been imprisoned for two years after a Bridgend hotel assault on two members of a stag party, which left one victim thinking, ‘this is it, I am dead.’

David Kelly, 47, of Lecky Road, Derry, appeared before Donegal Circuit Court, held at Letterkenny Courthouse, before Judge John Aylmer, after his matter came forward on a signed plea.

Kelly pleaded guilty to two counts of assault causing harm, contrary to Section 3 of the Non-Fatal Offences Against The Person Act 1997, on April 6, 2019, at the Frontier Hotel, Bridgend, against Jim Mulholland and Fintan McAfee.

He was sentenced to two-years imprisonment, after Judge Aylmer initially announced a headline sentence of three and a half years imprisonment.

Kelly’s Defence Barrister, Gareth McGrory BL, said he “reacted to what he perceived to be sectarian comments to him and they were loudly singing The Sash to which he asked them to stop.”

A victim had two front teeth permanently lost from the attack and had to attend a hospital in Craigavon, Co Armagh, for his injuries.

Fiona Crawford BL outlined details of the incident to the court. She said: “Both injured parties were at the Frontier Hotel on a stag party from the north of Ireland. They were all in the Residents' bar at two in the morning.

“They said the accused went absolutely crazy and was like an animal,

“The first victim lost two front teeth and went to hospital and needed dental work. He was kicked and stomped in the face.”

Ms Crawford said the second victim was “hit twice in the face and had a suspected broken nose.

“Gardaí arrived at the scene, and the accused gentleman had left. Both injured parties were too intoxicated to give a statement. CCTV was downloaded. The accused was identified.”

David Kelly had been identified after CCTV footage, which was played at court, was downloaded and handed over to the PSNI.

Ms Crawford continued: “The stag had outlined they were all in the hotel for two nights for his stag. They went out for a night in Derry and noticed a ‘bald fella with neck tattoos.’

She also quoted a victim who said Mr Kelly had attacked him, and started to kick him and felt a stomp. She said: “He was thinking, ‘this is it, I am dead.’” That victim lost his two front teeth.

Ms Crawford quoted a second witness, who said he ‘abruptly saw this man hit’ the first victim.

He said: “I went over to try to support him and calm things down. I then got punched in the face and fell across the table. I got up, and he hit me again. I was hit twice.”

The witness said that Mr Kelly then came over to the first victim and shook his hand.

Ms Crawford asked Garda Shauna Kerr if there was a reason why “this matter took so long,” considering it happened in 2019.

Garda Kerr answered that “there was an extradition warrant” and later said, following a question from Mr McGrory, that “Covid played a large part” in the time taken since the incident.

Mr McGrory said his client didn’t contest the extradition and that “he voluntarily surrendered himself.

“He has complied. He has complied with his bail conditions.”

Mr McGrory asked Garda Kerr if she was aware that “Mr Kelly had informed the Probation Officer that the reason why he reacted was that comments were made to him that he perceived to be sectarian.”

Garda Kerr replied: “I was only made aware of that recently.”

Mr McGrory stated: “The stag party were singing The Sash and he had asked them to refrain from doing so.”

Garda Kerr answered: “I was only aware of that recently. There is no sound on the CCTV.”

The court heard that Mr Kelly had 43 previous convictions in Northern Ireland, including four assaults, theft, public order, criminal damage, a drug related charge and four traffic related charges.

Mr McGrory commented: “The majority of these convictions occurred prior to 2019. Not to shy away from it, I think more serious than any of the convictions, his very first conviction in 1999 for armed robbery. Are you aware of that?”

Garda Kerr replied: “No.”

Mr McGrory said: “He is now 47 years old, a married man, originally from Brandywell with three children. He had limited education, an apprenticeship in bricklaying and worked up until the last number of years, until his diagnosis with arthritis in his hands.

“On the day of the offences, he was celebrating a friend's birthday party. He had been drinking all day. There had been some interaction between the parties prior to the assault.

“He reacted to what he perceived to be sectarian comments to him, and they were loudly singing The Sash, to which he asked them to stop. He admitted he was intoxicated at the time. He expresses his regret and wishes to apologise to Mr Mulholland and Mr McAfee.

“He knew then, in his state of intoxication, that his reaction was out of order. CCTV does make for distressing viewing, and Mr Kelly accepts that.

“This is a case that didn't involve any weapons, glasses or bottles.”

Judge Aylmer intervened: “I see he was involved in local boxing. In the lack of weapons, he was a boxer, and these are sufficient weapons.”

Mr McGrory responded: “He didn't reach for any glass or bottles.

“He was the victim of a very serious assault and suffered brain damage as a result, by a gang of men in Derry, and his memory has been affected.

“Garda Kerr agrees that the majority of offending occurs before 2019. Since this offence, he has been before the court in Northern Ireland on only one occasion, and he was sentenced to a month's imprisonment, suspended.

“It does seem that since 2019, he has largely turned the corner. This was undoubtedly a very unpleasant incident, but he has dealt with it the best he can.

“I asked the court that he be given maximum credit for the plea. He has also saved the victims the trauma of giving evidence. He has consented to a community service if the court is minded.”

Mr McGrory said that if the court was minded to giving Kelly a community service order, he could live at an address in Kilmacrennan temporarily if it “meant it could secure his liberty.”

He concluded: “He is not in a position to offer any sum of compensation but he does offer an apology and he expresses remorse.”

Judge Aylmer said: “Almost the entire incident was captured on CCTV footage. An aggravating feature of these assaults is that you were a boxer at a very high level, which explains your confident stance and posture as you took on a large group of young men.

“The assault involved numerous punches, which is very dangerous from a man who is a trained boxer. I don't place an awful lot of weight on the attachment on the fact that you did not reach for any weapons. Your fists were the weapon. Your punches were supplemented by kicking and stomping. An extremely dangerous act.

“You are very fortunate that more injuries were not suffered by the victims, albeit that Mr Mulholland lost his two front teeth permanently at a coast of £1,250 for dental treatment. Mr McAfee was fortunate to escape without a fractured nose.

“Another aggravating feature is the fact that you have a long list of previous convictions, including assault.

“It was fortuitous that one of the two victims didn't receive kicks to the head. The whole incident was very dangerous punches and very dangerous stomping on the victims.”

Judge Aylmer announced a headline sentence of three and a half years’ imprisonment.

He continued: “Mitigating circumstances. The most relevant is that you are before the court on a signed plea of guilty. That there is establishes, usually merits a one-third reduction on the sentence on its own. That has saved the victims from further trauma of a trial. It has also saved the state a significant inconvenience and expense.

“I note that you displayed remorse at the scene.

“I can not say you have not come to adverse attention since. You may have turned a corner, but there is some doubt about that with the conviction in Northern Ireland, but when one compares your record from before 2019, maybe there is some credence to that, and I will give you the benefit of the doubt.

“You have been behaving yourself an awful lot better since 2019.

“I am told you were the victim of a very serious assault and suffered a brain injury that has caused brain problems. Nothing in efforts or reports before me in relation to that.

“Taking all those factors into consideration, for the signed plea, I will reduce the sentence by 14 months and all the other matters, I will reduce the sentence of three and a half years to two years.”

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice