Mother of man who died after head blow incident describes ‘unimaginable sadness’

Fionntan McGarveyplaceholder image
Fionntan McGarvey

An inquest for Queen’s University student Fionntán McGarvey, 18, has opened in Belfast.

The mother of a teenager who died after being struck during an altercation outside a Belfast bar has spoken of the “unimaginable sadness” the family still endures.

Queen’s University student Fionntán McGarvey, 18, died more than three weeks after sustaining a blow to his head in an incident with another man outside the Devenish Complex in the Finaghy Road North area in the early hours of December 27 2021.

An inquest into his death opened on Monday at Belfast Coroner’s Court.

Mr McGarvey, who was a talented sportsman, sustained a fractured skull and blood clot on the surface of his brain.

He was discharged from hospital eight days after the incident but suffered a bleed on the brain one week later.

placeholder image

His condition rapidly deteriorated and he died in hospital 24 days after the initial altercation.

On the first day of the inquest, coroner Louisa Fee heard from several witnesses who were outside the bar when Mr McGarvey was struck by Conor Erskine following a verbal exchange between the two men.

Pathologist Dr James Lyness also told the court that while it was possible the secondary bleed on the brain was caused by the initial head injuries it was “difficult to state this categorically” from the post-mortem alone.

Prior to that evidence, the teenager’s mother Aveen paid tribute to her son from the witness stand.

“His death has brought an unimaginable sadness to us his parents, to his brothers Caolán, Dáire, his sister Sorcha, a loving extended family, and countless friends,” she told the court.

“Our loss is especially devastating by knowing the beautiful and loving young man he had become and realising just how much he wanted to give. Today we manage our grief by remembering who he was.”

Ms McGarvey said her son was happiest when in the company of teammates in the many sports clubs he played for.

“He would do anything for them and the bond they formed was so strong,” she said. “It was unbreakable. We know they will carry the memory of Fionntán in their hearts forever.”

Ms McGarvey said just before the incident “everything was falling into place” for her son.

“Seeing him so happy made us so happy,” she said.

“He was on the cusp of this beautiful life with everything to live for, and so much to do. That’s what makes us so sad.”

She added: “Our memories of Fionntán are so precious because they are the only ones we will ever have. We take comfort from knowing that he was our beautiful gift, our Fionntán.”

Ms McGarvey described the family’s pride that her son had donated his organs in his “final and greatest act of love”.

Counsel to the coroner Ian Skelt KC told the court that much of the evidence at the inquest will centre on the investigation into the events outside the Devenish. Mr Skelt said it “appears settled” that the medical treatment Mr McGarvey received in the weeks after the incident was “appropriate”.

Describing the event, Mr Skelt told the court that Mr Erskine had struck Mr McGarvey on the head, causing him to fall to the ground and hit his head on the concrete.

Mr Skelt said Mr Erskine claims he was approached by Mr McGarvey, who appeared intoxicated and was being aggressive towards him.

“He said that he saw Fionntán make a movement of sorts that he took to be a risk of being struck by Fionntán, so he struck Fionntán,” the barrister told the court.

“He described this as just one swing.”

Witness Peter Fitzpatrick, who said he considered Mr Erskine as his best friend, described the incident in a statement read to court. He said they both had been at Down Royal for the Boxing Day racing meet during the day with a group of other friends and had continued to socialise in the Devenish that night.

He said tensions flared between Mr Erskine and Mr McGarvey outside the bar at the end of the night when the latter approached the former.

“There was no history between them,” he said.

“I’d never seen Conor get into a fight on a night out.”

He recalled how the two men walked around the corner to a car park close to the train station. He said he followed but was not looking directly at the pair when the blow was struck.

“I heard a thud and turned round and could see Fionntán lying on the ground, and Conor was quickly getting down to help him,” he said.

He added: “A few people pulled Conor back. He was panicking and extremely worried about Fionntán. I then went over to help Conor, who was in tears.”

Giving evidence remotely, Mr Fitzpatrick was asked by legal representatives if he could recall Mr Erskine saying anything to him as they walked home after the incident.

“I wouldn’t remember anything specifically, just that he was very upset,” he said.

Jade Rooney, who told the court she knew Mr Erskine very well, said she had been speaking to him outside the bar when Mr McGarvey approached him in the car park area and said “fight me”.

“There was no laughing involved,” she said in a statement.

“He was glaring Conor directly in the eye and barely blinked. They didn’t seem to be listening to anyone, and both just seemed completely engaged with each other. Conor had said to Fionntán, ‘mate, you don’t want to do this – let’s not fight’.”

She said Mr McGarvey left the scene but then returned soon afterwards.

“He was quite persistent that he wanted to continue to fight,” she said.

“Fionntán said to Conor, ‘I’m going to f****** kill you’.

“Fionntán was staring at Conor directly in the eye. I found this very threatening, and this started to concern me a little bit.

“I was telling them both to stop, but Fionntán just proceeded to provoke it. It was almost like Fionntán was pushing Conor’s buttons.”

She said the two men then went round the corner to “talk”.

“The next thing I saw was Conor’s right arm went straight out and hit Fionntán a quick punch on the ear. I could hear the force of it.

“It did seem forceful, but it didn’t seem one that would be if he intentionally wanted to hurt him.”

Karen Quinlivan KC, representing Mr Erskine, said he claims he slapped Mr McGarvey with an open hand, and did not punch him.

Putting that to Ms Rooney, the witness responded: “I can’t comment on that. I’m sorry. I just remember his arm striking out.”

Ms Rooney, who was first aid-trained, helped treat Mr McGarvey at the scene.

The court heard that emergency call handlers advised that an ambulance could take as long as three hours to attend.

Police ultimately transported Mr McGarvey to the Royal Victoria Hospital.

Another one of Mr Erskine’s friends, Oran McIlhatton, witnessed the incident unfold in the car park.

“Fionntán appeared to be instantly knocked out, his chin dropped to his chest, and he seemed to just go stiff from the neck down,” he said.

“He fell straight back like a plank and saw him hit the ground.

“His body hit the ground first, and his head snapped back, and struck the ground with a loud, massive thud.”

The court heard that Mr McIlhatton told investigating officers that prior to the incident Mr Erskine had come up to him and Mr Fitzpatrick and asked them to hold his jacket as Mr McGarvey wanted to fight him.

Eugene McKenna, representing the McGarvey family, asked Mr McIlhatton did he believe Mr Erskine had taken off his jacket and rolled up his sleeves because he was preparing for a fight.

The witness agreed.

Ms Quinlivan then put it to Mr McIlhatton that Mr Fitzpatrick did not recall Mr Erskine handing him his jacket, while Ms Rooney said Mr Erskine had given her a jacket to help her keep warm.

“I can only say what I’ve seen,” he replied.

Ms Quinlivan also challenged Mr McIlhatton on his recollection that Mr Erskine used his left arm to strike Mr McGarvey.

She noted that Mr Erskine claimed he used his right hand and Ms Rooney also said the blow was struck with the right hand.

Asked if he could be wrong that Mr Erskine used his left hand, Mr McIlhatton replied “possibly”.

In the final evidence of the day, a police officer described attending the scene and explained the decision to transport Mr McGarvey to hospital due the issues with ambulance availability.

The case continues.

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice