PAUL McFLYNN: Dual players should be celebrated

A RECENT discussion between Donal Og Cusack and Ger Loughnane on The Sunday Game got me thinking about the difficulties that dual players face.

Cusack and Loughnane both insisted that the decision to allow ‘Podge’ Collins to play football and hurling for Clare was wrong, as was the decision to allow Cork duo Aidan Walsh and Eoin Cadogan to do the same.

Many would accept that attempting to play both at county level is not possible if you want to be at the top of your game but what is more worrying is that the dual club player is now becoming a rarity due to the high demands that are placed on club players.

Many club managers have a training plan which requires players to train at least three times per week with a game at the weekend. Now this is just for one code so when you consider the demands on the dual player you can perhaps understand why less and less players commit to both.

These players are the players we should be highlighting as role models to kids, players that have the talent and attitude to commit to two sports. 

Many will argue that they should play the sport that they are best at, while others will say that they should play the sport that they love the most.

I currently manage at a dual club where between the senior football and hurling squads we have nine dual players. These boys play 18 league games for football and 18 league games for hurling and when you take challenge games, cup games and championship games into the equation, some will play 50 plus games during the season.

I'm not saying that this is easy to coordinate, it's not, but communication between myself and the senior hurling manager means that we put the players first.

For example, when the hurlers have a game on a Sunday and we are training on a Saturday evening, the dual players will tog out and only do certain parts of the session.

If we happen to be doing specific fitness work, they will sit this out so that they are fresh for their game the next day.

It also works the other way where the hurling manager will text me saying that the dual men will only do stick work with him if they are training the day before a football game.

This understanding and appreciation that each sport is as important as the other is of fundamental importance.

There are dual players in this club that would play tiddlywinks for their club because to them they are representing their club and parish and that's all that matters.

Unfortunately in certain clubs you have club members who make assumptions about dual players in terms of which sport is their first love.

From my current experience as a manager with nine dual players, I do not see one player who has a preference for either sport. I see boys who are prepared to make huge sacrifices to play two sports for their club.

I have no doubt there are dual players in other clubs who have a slight preference for one sport. Is this a crime? Surely they can prefer one to the other but still be committed to both.

We are all aware of stories that do the rounds regarding the tensions that exist in certain clubs, some perhaps exaggerated, some not.

I am not from a dual club but my experience over the years has taught me that dual players should receive the highest possible adulation. 

My view is that these players devote more time to their club than the player who simply plays football or hurling only.

It is no surprise that the reduction in dual players can be correlated with the rise in professionalism and commitment that has developed over the past ten years.

Can we expect dual club players to train 5 times per week with possible games at weekends?

Of course not.

Common sense would tell you that these players will do this for a certain period of time until they get demotivated and eventually injured.

Some clubs and management teams seem to forget that the most important people in this are the players, players who devote 15 or 16 hours per week for their club.

Many will say that of course they put the players first but placing unrealistic demands on players and the creation of pressure to put more into one game than the other is unfair.

I am aware that the situation in each dual club is different but it would appear that in certain clubs you have a minority of individuals who would 'burn the hurls' and others who would stick a knife in an O’Neill’s size 5.

The adoption of such attitudes is detrimental to both codes because dual players will be aware of certain personalities in their club who have a negative attitude towards the other code and vice versa.

For example, picture yourself playing on a football squad and you know that one of the management team dislikes hurling as he makes no attempt to hide his feelings.

From your perspective you simply love playing both games and want to succeed at both. However, here is a club man who is belittling your efforts and almost wishing you little success in hurling.

When this individual is coaching you and giving you instructions, will you have the utmost respect to do your very best or will you be operating at 95%?

What some people seem to forget is that these men are human beings who deserve to be respected for their efforts and, if they possess the talent to play both codes, then this should be celebrated.

Some will argue that if you have a high number of dual players you cannot expect to be successful. I have no doubt that achieving success may be more difficult but it can be done.

There is almost the opinion if the dual player misses a tough football training session then they are losing out and the same if they happen to miss a hurling session.

When my dual players miss a football session because they have a hurling game the next day, do they lose out? 

Of course they don't lose out, in fact, I believe they benefit because they will do more running in the hurling game as well as be involved in a proper competitive game. The game is as good as 5 training sessions!

A proper co-ordinated training schedule needs to be drawn up between both management teams and open lines of communication the norm.

I was speaking to a dual player from a Derry club recently who told me that it's as if both management teams don't trust each other. When players pick up on these vibes, it creates disharmony.

The hurling coach must trust the football coach to do the specific fitness work they agreed on and vice versa.

The creation of positive relationships and a well co-ordinated training plan will help everyone concerned, particularly the players, who will see that their efforts are being recognised by both management teams

When players are happy and content, then you have a chance of getting the best out of them but when they are annoyed or disgruntled then you will never get the best out of them.

I am really enjoying my stint as a manger in a dual club.  As a football manager I am delighted to have dual players because from what I observe, the dual men bring a new dimension to a football team as most possess a very simplistic and highly committed attitude towards the game where they simply play without any fuss.

They are my quiet players. It reminds me of a story I tell many times when I speak to a hurling man.

When I started teaching in St Louis Ballymena I encountered a very passionate year 8 hurler from Dunloy. I was having a bit of banter with him one day explaining to him how football was a better game.

He didn't say much that day leaving me thinking that I had gotten the better of him. The next morning as I approached the staff room door, there he was waiting for me.

He said, 'sir, I have something for you' and he handed me a piece of paper and then walked away. I opened the paper and read 'football is for men but hurling is for heroes'.

I couldn't help but laugh and it got me thinking. This young lad from Dunloy believed that hurling was the superior sport and provided me with many reasons why he believed this.

This same lad played football and hurling for the school for seven years and in terms of rating his commitment, he was equally committed to football as he was hurling. As it turns out, he still plays football and hurling for Dunloy.

If clubs can produce highly talented individuals who possess the desire and commitment to play both games then this should be celebrated, encouraged and used as a positive. 

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice