Derry's David Simpson just misses on prestigious Derby double


Agria Derby Trial winner secures second place in a thrilling Al Shira’aa Derby jump-off.
Derry's David Simpson came very close to securing a coveted Hickstead double last week, having won Friday’s Agria Derby Trial and finished second in Sunday’s Al Shira’aa Derby, both with the 11-year-old Pjotr Van De Kruishoeve.
A total of 45 riders came forward for the Trial, which acts as a qualifier for the Derby. With 19 jumping efforts and a time allowed of just under 2min, the Agria Derby Trial is longer than most international showjumping classes, and normally there are only a few clears each year. But this year, six combinations produced first round clears to go through to the jump-off.
William Whitaker (Flamboyant III) and Guy Williams (BH Gringos Legacy) opted not to jump for a second time to save their horses for Sunday, leaving four combinations to contest the final honours in this World Ranking class.
Event rider Alex Bragg and the grey mare Hegglelane Houston produced the first of the double clears to take the lead, but David Simpson matched the clear round on his 2023 Derby champion Pjotr Van De Kruishoeve, using the horse’s effortless pace and long stride to knock nearly 6sec off Alex’s time. It was a second Agria Derby Trial title for David, who first won on Gotti Van Paemel in 2016.
Simpson was among the firm favourites to win again in Sunday’s Al Shira’aa Derby, in which a strong contingent of 30 horse-and-rider combinations came forwards to compete for their share of the €120,000 prize fund. The first of the clear rounds came from David and Pjotr Van De Kruishoeve, who survived a few near-misses during their faultless round – the first at the wall at fence five, and then when the top pole of the final part of the Devil’s Dyke flew up into the air but landed back in the cups.
William Whitaker, a winner of this class exactly 10 years ago with Glenavadra Brilliant, provided the only other clear round to guarantee a jump-off. First to go round the shortened course against the clock, David and the 11-year-old Pjotr set off at pace, determined to put the pressure on William. This time Simpson’s luck ran out in the Devil’s Dyke combination, when the middle part fell, but their fast time of 86.26sec piled pressure on his rival.
Whitaker was left in a tricky predicament – did he try to match David’s pace, or aim for a steady clear with the 16-year-old Flamboyant III? William opted for the latter, and after missing out in the jump-offs in both 2024 and 2025 to finish runner-up twice, this time the pair left all the fences standing to give William a second Derby title.
While Simpson was disappointed not to join the ranks of two-time Derby winners, he gave credit to his horse for jumping two super rounds. “Pjotr loves it here at Hickstead, and I was delighted with how he was today. His next target is to come back here in July for the Nations Cup and the Grand Prix. That’s the good thing about him, he can do Derbies, he can do five-star Grands Prix. I’m very lucky to have him.”