McKinless given hope by DRA


DERRY and Ballinderry defender Gareth McKinless could be free to play this summer following the decision of the GAA's Disputes Resolution Authority (DRA) on his appeal. The Shamrocks man had been handed three concurrent 48-week suspensions following alleged incidents at the end of last October’s county final, in which his club were beaten by a last-minute Slaughtneil goal. Having had his appeals turned down by the Derry, Ulster and Central Hearings Committees, McKinless’ case was heard by the DRA on May 19. The independent panel has released their findings through their website today and they have thrown out two of the three suspensions. McKinless had been accused of assaulting an umpire, “slapping” a linesman and making a “hand/arm movement” as players, officials, stewards and spectators left the Celtic Park pitch through a gate behind the goal. The latter had not been mentioned specifically in the referee’s report but was brought as a result of a DVD showing the events at the end of the game. The first and third suspensions have been struck out on the basis that the DVD evidence “did not give a clear, continuous and unobstructed view of the incident,” said the DRA’s findings. “The evidence used in relation to the first and third infraction was not of sufficient quality. “The rules contained within the Official Guide grant appropriate discretion in decision-making to the appropriate bodies….It cannot be said that the discretion is exercisable fairly or reasonably where inherently poor video evidence was the only basis for the laying of the first and third infractions.” The other allegation, of “slapping” the linesman, was also struck out by the tribunal but referred back to Ulster Hearings Committee for “reconsideration.” DRA have told Ulster Council in their findings on that matter that they are “directed to require clarification from the referee on the nature of the contact prior to their reconsideration on the matter.” Their findings further state: “It shall be a matter for [Ulster Hearings] to determine whether the clarification results in the matter being considered under Rule 7.2 (b) category V or VI. Therefore [Ulster Hearings] should make a finding on the matter.” Derry senior football manager Brian McIver attended the meeting “upon an indication that he may have been called as a witness by the claimant,” but he was not called to give evidence. It’s understood that McKinless has indicated a willingness to return to the county panel. But despite being cleared of two of the bans handed down, McKinless remains under suspension until a decision is made on the third case by Ulster. As things stand, he will remain unable to play for his club or county until mid-September. He was represented through the appeals process by high-profile county Tyrone lawyer Feargal Logan. Ballinderry have already seen the 48-week ban handed down to Michael Conlan rescinded and Aaron Devlin’s suspension reduced to 8 weeks on appeal by Ulster Hearings, with both now back playing. Devlin had initially also been also handed a 48-week ban, but his was in a landmark case for comments he made on social media after the match. However, there were doubts over how his punishment would stand up and it was subsequently reduced to eight weeks. The club’s £5,000 fine - which was handed down by Derry Hearings as a reduction of the punishment which was to see their pitch closed for a year – was also cut to £2,000.