Fewer games hurt Derry hurling growth warns Na Magha ace


Na Magha dual player Deaghlan Foley warns that slashing fixture numbers damages grassroots growth and starves smaller clubs of vital income
The Leadon Timber Frames Derry Hurling Championship gets underway this weekend, with city club Na Magha handed the toughest possible opening assignment as they face reigning champions Slaughtneil.
Robert Emmets begin their quest for a remarkable fourteenth consecutive Fr Collins Cup, and, for the third successive season, their championship campaign opens against the city side.
This year's championship has undergone a major overhaul. The previous group-stage format has been scrapped in favour of an open draw followed by winners' and losers' brackets.
The new system means one defeat immediately ends a team's hopes of winning the senior title, while two victories are enough to book a place in the county final.
While Slaughtneil remain overwhelming favourites to retain their crown and will already have ambitions far beyond the county championship, the revised structure has raised concerns among many of Derry's developing clubs.
Under the previous format, teams were guaranteed at least four championship matches. Now, clubs can see their season over after just two games, something Derry hurler and Na Magha star Deaghlan Foley believes is damaging to the growth of the game within the county, despite what has been a remarkable year for the game at intercounty level.
“If hurling is going to continue growing in Derry, we need more competitive games, not fewer. I just don't see how the new structure helps that,” he said. “For clubs like Na Magha, we tend to improve as the championship goes on. We build into competitions, so having fewer games doesn't suit us at all. You want players hurling as often as possible, and this new format doesn't encourage that.
“Even in the league we only play each team once. It's fine for us who are in with the county team; we're training and playing matches all year round, but for some lads, you're talking about maybe nine games across the entire year.
“Those of us involved with the county are fortunate but club-only players don't have that. I genuinely don't understand the reasoning behind reducing the number of games. It just feels like they are trying to get it out of the way as soon as possible.”
Despite those concerns, Derry hurling has never enjoyed greater momentum at county level. However, for clubs like Na Magha, the challenge is very different.
Competing for players and attention in a city where Gaelic football and soccer reign supreme, regular competitive fixtures are essential to maintaining interest, developing players and ensuring the club continues to grow.
The restructuring also has financial implications. The previous championship guaranteed each club a home fixture, providing valuable gate receipts. That opportunity has now disappeared. Even so, the Derry panellist is relishing another opportunity for the city men to test themselves against one of the country's elite club hurling teams.
“You were guaranteed three games before: home, away and a neutral venue. That home championship game was important for gate receipts and fundraising. Now, if you lose your first two games, your championship is finished by the end of August. That's far from ideal.
“We're competing with Gaelic football and soccer, so it's not easy. We've had plenty of lads over the years who were excellent dual players but eventually committed to football and went on to have great success. That's just the reality of being in a predominantly football county.
“We usually don't really hit our stride until the championship, and we tend to get better as the competition goes on. Obviously we've been drawn against Slaughtneil, but you want to play the best teams as often as you can because that's how you improve. You always come away having learned something.”