CAHAIR O'KANE: McGuinness will go down as one of the greatest

So how do Jim McGuinness' achievements stack beside the 'greats'?

After four years, it was announced late last night, too late for print, that the Glenties man had stepped down as Donegal manager.

No-one will be unduly surprised. By the timing of it, perhaps. But not that he is gone.

He could have stayed as long as he wished, of course. He could have stayed and tried to build a dynasty.

Maybe he saw a barren spell ahead. Maybe it was that he had bled every ounce he could from this Donegal team. With Lacey, Gallagher, McFadden, Durcan all getting on a bit in years, there is that notion that they've had their run at it. Time will tell.

But if it is the case, then that team can retire with much less regret than had McGuinness not come on the scene. It would be no shock to suggest that tgey would have won nothing without him.

Instead, they have three Ulster medals, one All-Ireland, the experience of beating Dublin that afternoon, of playing in four straight Ulster finals. They have had a stunning four years.

Their manager made it happen. Laughed out of the room the first time he went for it, he wasn't being laughed at when he took the under-21s to within the width of the bar of a first ever All-Ireland title.

When they reached the 2011 Ulster final, they hadn't won one in 19 years. Derry hadn't won one in 18 years. But there was a different determination about Donegal. Even then, you could see that Ulster wasn't going to be enough.

They lost the infamous semi-final to Dublin but the following year, they blew all out of their paths.

They would bring Sam back to the Hills. The second time the opportunity came around, they couldn't quite take it. And by his post match comments, Jim McGuinness will leave with the nagging regret that his team didn't perform against Kerry, and missed out on that second All-Ireland.

It would be unfair to say that Donegal won't realise what they had until it's now gone. You could always gauge the sense from Donegal people over the last few years that they knew they were going to have to squeeze every medal they could from his tenure.

All his strengths were widely lauded. His tactical knowledge was put at the head of his CV, but it was always secondary to his other skills.

How did he get that Donegal team to park their lives - and that's what they did - in pursuit of what was essentially a pipe dream when he took over? To get them to still believe that it was possible after losing to Dublin in 2011, and to get them back to near that level this year again after they seemed to be headed thr other way?

The medals and trophies they won were by consequence of the belief and motivation he instilled.

Brian Cody, Mick O'Dwyer, Kevin Heffernan, they will go down as the greats. Does McGuinness deserve to join the pantheon?

He didn't win as much. Had he stayed, he still wouldn't have. There weren't eight or nine All-Irelands in that Donegal team.

But five years ago, there wasn't even an Ulster in them. The trophy count might not sit on a par with those men but the achievement, the manner of it, and the revolutionary style he brought, make Jim McGuinness one of the great GAA managers of all time.

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice