What I really said… Dr Anne McCloskey

placeholder image

During a public debate last week involving a number of the Foyle candidates in the upcoming Assembly elections, one of the candidates, independent Dr Anne McCloskey said: “I think women’s liberation has got us to a very bad place for a lot of young women who regard themselves as receptacles for semen and if they don’t want it they can get rid of it.” Her comments, which were made during a discussion on abortion, attracted criticism from other candidates on the panel. Here, Dr McCloskey responds to the criticism. On reading the local newspapers and social media this week I see that I’ve been subjected to a bit of selective editing by the pro-abortion lobby who are standing in the upcoming elections.

Although my campaign is based around issues affecting people’s daily lives such as poverty, unemployment, lack of services and so on, the abortion question keeps turning up anywhere the enthusiasts gather.

Their sensitivities were offended, it seems, by my discussion of the issues I deal with daily as a GP, regarding women, men and frequently children who are sexually active, and at risk of unplanned pregnancy and sexually transmitted infections.

What I was trying to convey, in terms which were misinterpreted, or maybe just misunderstood, was the vulnerability and low self-esteem of many women in our society.

In doing so I used arguments and terminology which are well rehearsed in feminist literature, but which were obviously were not appreciated by those present.

Popular culture often reduces women to sex objects, and some have not the tools to fight back.

Many suffer from hopelessness and low self-worth compounded by educational disadvantage, unemployment or zero hours contracts, low wages, drugs, alcohol and lack of social support.

Their relentless comparison with photo-shopped, surgically enhanced perfection increases their vulnerability.

Likewise, young men often have expectations driven by what they download onto their phones from the internet-not likely to provide healthy models for successful and meaningful relationships.

Peer pressure means that often they measure their worth in terms of conquests. They too are victims.

These are complex issues, but honest discussion should not be feared, much less vilified.

Abortion is not the answer, and no amount of pseudo-lefty dogma-spouting will change this.

Socialists will recognise the difference between accepting received wisdom, and addressing a complex issue by reasoned analysis.

My opinions on this subject have been informed by 30 years in the medical profession.

As a registrar in the perinatal paediatric intensive care unit in the Royal Victoria Hospital in Belfast, I became convinced of the humanity of the pre-born child.

Working for 25 years as a GP in one of Derry’s most deprived areas means that talk I to real people about their health and relationships.

These experiences daily affirm my view that abortion is never the solution.

It reduces the wonder of human reproduction to a function in which the child has no autonomy but is merely the subject of someone else’s requirements.

Maeve Mc Laughlin said that my views were “a gross insult to all women.”

I advocate for women daily. She has accused me of arguing “that women should return to a subservient position.”

I want all women to be empowered to do everything which they want with their lives.

She implied that I am not concerned about the welfare of women in this town. I am very concerned.

My views are clear. Should Maeve or any of my other critics wish to debate this subject in a public forum, name the time and venue and I’ll be there.

Photo shows Dr McCloskey (right) speaking during last week’s debate. Included from left are election candidates Eamon McCann (People Before Profit), Gerard Diver (SDLP) and Maeve McLaughlin (Sinn Fein).

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice