Mental Health champion launches new report


‘The Economic Case for a Mental Health Regional Crisis Intervention Service in Northern Ireland’
The North’s Mental Health Champion Professor Siobhan O'Neill has launched her latest report: "The Economic Case for a Mental Health Regional Crisis Intervention Service in Northern Ireland."
A key theme of the report, launched on Thursday, June 25, was Scotland's Distress Brief Intervention (DBI) programme and the evidence that early, compassionate, community-based support can improve outcomes for people in distress while also delivering significant economic benefits.
A spokesperson for PIPS Suicide Prevention Charity described the report as making “a strong, compelling case for investing in a regional crisis intervention service modelled on Scotland's DBI programme”.
They said: “The findings in this report are striking. Mental health crises cost NI more than £45 million every year, and Scotland's DBI programme provides up to 14 days of community-based support for people in distress at an average cost of £392 per person, compared with around £544 for a single Emergency Department visit in NI.
“Against this evidenced backdrop, it is difficult to understand why NI is pursuing the Right Care Right Person model (RCRP),” added the spokesperson.
“RCRP is built on the principle that PSNI should no longer respond to incidents where there is no crime, no immediate threat to life and no policing purpose, with responsibility instead passing to Ambulance Services.
“In principle, people experiencing mental distress deserve the right care from the right service. But in practice, without the right support services in place, RCRP risks withdrawing police from the frontline before there is a safe and effective alternative for those in crisis.
“The question the Executive must answer now is this: ‘Has it built and invested in the necessary services needed to make RCRP safe?’
“If police are stepping back from responding to people experiencing mental distress, what added crisis intervention services have been put in place to ensure those individuals receive timely, effective and compassionate support, when ambulances are already tied up for many hours,” said the spokesperson.
“This report demonstrates exactly what those services could look like and why they make both clinical and economic sense,” they added.
“This concern is not theoretical. In England, Coroners' Prevention of Future Deaths reports have already raised concerns about RCRP, including cases where police did not attend incidents involving people in acute mental distress and where gaps between policing and health services may have left vulnerable people without an effective emergency response. That should be a serious warning for us all in Northern Ireland.
“Without investment in alternatives there is real risk that RCRP simply removes one part of the emergency response system without creating the safety net people need. This report demonstrates that there is another way, one that is both compassionate and economically sound.
“At the same time, the Northern Ireland Executive continues to say there is not enough funding to fully deliver the Mental Health Strategy. This report is a powerful example of why failing to fund the Strategy is a false economy. It demonstrates that investing in early intervention and community-based crisis services not only improves outcomes for people in distress, but reduces demand on emergency departments, ambulance services and policing, delivering significant savings in the process. The real question is not whether we can afford to invest in mental health, it is whether we can afford not to.
“This is exactly why we continue to campaign through our ‘Too Many Lives Lost’ campaign. Every life lost to suicide is one too many. We cannot continue to accept a system that responds only when people have reached crisis point while delaying investment in services that we know save lives, improve outcomes and reduce costs. The evidence is there. The economic case is there. What is needed now is the political will to act,” said the spokesperson.
‘Early, compassionate, community-based support can improve outcomes for people in distress while also delivering significant economic benefits’
“We cannot remove one part of the system before building another. If we truly want the right care from the right person, we must first ensure the right services exist. Because every delay in delivering the Mental Health Strategy risks more people falling through the gaps and too many lives have already been lost.”
Professof O’Neill’s report can be read here: https://www.mentalhealthchampion-ni.org.uk/publications/economic-case-mental health-regional-crisis-intervention-service-northern-ireland.