Public inquiry sought into death of Katie Simpson whistleblower


Heartbroken family demands justice from the PSNI after review vindicates Paul Lusby
The lifelong friend of a whistleblower continually dismissed by PSNI personnel investigating the death of Katie Simpson has called for a public inquiry into the circumstances surrounding his death.
Derry man Paul Lusby repeatedly and unsuccessfully attempted to warn the PSNI Jonathan Creswell had murdered the young showjumper, contrary to Creswell’s claims she had taken her own life.
According to his friend, Davy McAuley, Mr Lusby was completely vindicated in Dr Jan Melia’s recently published ‘Katie Simpson Review’ (April 27, 2026). The full report can be read HERE.
As a result, the community activist is calling for a public inquiry into Mr Lusby’s treatment by the PSNI and why it failed to act on the information he provided.
In the Reviewer’s Forward to her report, which examined how Ms Simpson’s death in August 2020 was handled by the PSNI, Dr Jan Melia wrote: “The death of Paul Lusby who helped raise the alarm about Jonathan Creswell is also acknowledged, he was Katie’s friend, and a much loved father and husband, who is greatly missed by his family and friends.
“I wish to extend my condolences to them and hope that this report goes someway to highlighting his efforts to raise the alarm about Jonathan Creswell.”
She later referenced Mr Lusby’s tragic death on July 14, 2022, writing: “At interview in July 2025, [Mr Lusby’s] widow stated that she felt that had there not been a delay in the police investigation, Paul would not have been impacted so severely.”
In Conclusion 20 of her Review, the current domestic homicide review chairperson and former CEO of the Women’s Aid Federation NI, said: “Paul Lusby felt intimidated by Jonathan Creswell after cooperating with police. The prolonged delay in the investigation is understood by his family to have significantly exacerbated his distress, ultimately contributing to his death.”
“The death of Katie Simpson and the subsequent handling of the investigation by police have raised serious questions about competence, accountability, and the protection of vulnerable individuals. The PSNI must rebuild trust,” wrote Dr Melia.
Mr McAuley was adamant Paul Lusby would still be alive if the PSNI had taken the measures they should have straight away.
“I think there should be some kind of public inquiry into the role of the police because it would appear there are a lot of questions which need answers,” said Mr McAuley.
“I know the Review speaks about ‘misogyny’ but there were clear failings beyond that,” he added, “not least the fact there is a ridiculous rule that if a member of the PSNI retires, they can no longer be investigated, that has to be overturned,” he added.
“I think the police officers involved should face criminal charges on the back of this Review because Paul has lost his life as a result of their actions.
“Such a public inquiry should also address all of the circumstances surrounding Creswell’s repeat offending, prior to Katie Simpson’s death, all of which was ignored.
In addition, it must examine the fact that, when presented with this overwhelming evidence, the PSNI took a contrary view, even when it continued to be pressured,” said Mr McAuley.
“The PSNI were completely uncooperative during any investigation,” added Mr McAuley and when there finally was an investigation, the police officer who carried it out left the PSNI immediately after.
“I would also like senior PSNI figures who now have a political role, like Jon Burrows, to come out and say what he actually knows. To claim he never heard a misogynistic word uttered is unbelievable.
“I think it's really, really important to establish some justice for Paul because he has been written out of this story so much and for such a long time. I think it is only fair for Paul’s siblings and his mum and dad. I know all of this has taken a terrible toll on them. It would only be fair to do the right thing,” said Mr McAuley.
Recalling his friend, Mr McAuley said he had known Mr Lusby since they did their A’Levels together at Foyle College.
“We got on very well. I went into Seagate a year after leaving Foyle and a short time later Paul came into Seagate too. If I was staying out in my parents home in Drumahoe, Paul would have given me a lift in and we had great craic. He was a very good fella.
“I’d say the reason Paul contacted me straight away is because I have been involved in a lot of activism and community campaigns.
“The information he was telling me at times, if it was overwhelming me, it was definitely overwhelming him because he was living every minute of it.
“His mum messaged me and thanked me for talking about Paul. Anything I’ve tried to do I always sought approval from them because they have lost their son and you wouldn’t want to upset them.”