Judge suggests insurance companies should face tighter regulation after Derry man is charged with having no insurance when he had paid for a policy
A local judge has suggested that insurance companies should face tighter regulation after a Derry man was charged with having no insurance when he had paid for a policy. Joseph Brown, 50, with an address on his charge sheet of High Street in Derry, was charged with using a motor vehicle without insurance on October 5, 2016. The defendant paid to cover a vehicle which he was picking up in Derry and driving to an address over the border. However, according to the Public Prosecution Service the insurance only covered the vehicle registration in the Republic of Ireland, which is why the police stopped him on London Street and he was subsequently charged. District Judge Barney McElholm said the insurance company would have known it was a Northern Ireland registered vehicle when Brown paid for his policy. He added: “These people were quite happy to take his money…the treatment of their client is quite appalling.” Defence solicitor Michael McGee said he had tried to speak to the insurance company directly, which is based in Donegal Town, but they have refused to discuss the matter. The judge suggested there should be an ombudsman in place to investigate complaints against insurance companies. He said he didn’t regard it as the defendant’s fault and if the company was based in Derry he would summons them to appear before the court. “Besides a common lack of courtesy in not responding, it Is very very poor service,” added Judge McElholm. The case was taken to February 8 when the judge hoped it would be possible to ‘squeeze some information out these lamentable people.’