Inquest told more 'could and should have been done' to save Derry man's life


An inquest into the death of a Derry man was this week told that there ‘could and should have been more done to help’ him.
The remarks were made by the Coroner Joe McGrisken during the inquest into the death of 49-year-old Martin Doherty of Great James Street who died on March 23 last year.
Mr Doherty, a former Merchant Seaman, died from lobar pneumonia with a fatty liver due to prolonged heavy drinking cited as a contributory factor.
However, he had no alcohol in his system at the time of his death.
The inquest heard that workers for a Night Support Service which works with homeless people and street drinkers were contacted about a man who collapsed outside an off-licence in Sackville Street on March 22, 2016.
The employee of the off-licence had seen Mr Doherty and believed him to be intoxicated and contacted the Night Support Service at 8.15pm.
A support worker giving evidence at the inquest said that he also believed Mr Doherty to be in ‘an extremely intoxicated state’ due to his state of confusion and inability to support himself or walk.
Mr Doherty was able to identify himself and give his address and was helped to his flat in Great James Street.
When they arrived there, a man working at another nearby property was leaving out bins and came over to assist the outreach workers.
The men were able to help Mr Doherty into the hallway of the flats but could not carry him to his flat, which was on the top floor.
As it was impossible to carry him to his flat, Mr Doherty was made comfortable by placing a pillow under his head and a coat around him and he lay on the steps in the hallway where he appeared to go to sleep.
He was said to have been pale, drifting in and out of consciousness and ‘foaming slightly at the mouth’.
The Night Support workers received another call for assistance and had to leave but told the maintenance worker who remained with Mr Doherty that they would phone an ambulance.
The ambulance was phoned at 9.28pm.
A recording of the 999 call was played to the court. The Night Support worker told the ambulance control operator that Mr Doherty appeared ‘extremely intoxicated’.
The ambulance control operator said, ‘So he’s just drunk.’
The Night Support worker said that Mr Doherty was drifting in and out of consciousness and was foaming slightly at the mouth and was ‘breathing ok’. He added that Mr Doherty was pale and grey but ‘not scarily grey or pale’.
The Night Support worker also said he did not think Mr Doherty had ingested drugs but that he had not prior knowledge of him and did not know whether he was on medication or had any other underlying medical issues.
The ambulance control operator took the Night Support worker’s phone number and told him an ambulance would be despatched.
Coroner McGriskin said: “We know now that Mr Doherty didn’t have any drink taken. It was clear he had a serious physical condition which could well have been mistaken for being intoxicated.”
However, he added that, as Mr Doherty had collapsed outside an off-licence and appeared intoxicated, that there was ‘no reason you should question this’ and would have ‘put two and two together’.
The maintenance worker who remained with Mr Doherty said that he would ‘keep an eye’ on him.
He said that he had appeared to ‘into a deep sleep from drink’ and that he ‘tried to wake him but it was no use’.
So the man went about his business, checking in on Mr Doherty a few times and awaiting the ambulance.
However, by around 10pm there was still no sign of an ambulance and the man went home after checking Mr Doherty was comfortable and still breathing.
He said that when he had left him, Mr Doherty had been ‘sound asleep and snoring’.
The man said that he didn’t have a number to contact the Night Support worker but that he knew there were other people in the building and assumed they would open the door when the ambulance workers arrived to gain access.
Paramedics who responded to the incident also gave evidence in court.
The first ambulance worker said that they had responded to the call concerning Mr Doherty at 10.26pm and arrived at 10.34pm, over an hour after the 999 call.
The ambulance that responded had been based in Castlederg as ambulances in the Derry and the surrounding areas were busy.
The paramedic said that he and his colleague had knocked on the door and rang a number of bells at the flats and no one responded.
He said that they had looked in windows and knocked on windows but that no one answered.
He said they contacted ambulance control who told them they had tried to contact the Night Support worker by phone a number of times but that there had been no answer.
He said that they had been told someone was with Mr Doherty.
A second member of the ambulance crew reiterated this and said that he believed he looked in the letterbox but that it would have been too dark to see Mr Doherty lying in the hallway and that the blinds were closed at the windows.
He said: ‘We did everything we could’.
Mr Doherty’s father suggested in court that it should be compulsory for paramedics to carry torches as they may have spotted his son if they had shone a torch through the letterbox.
He also said that the decision to let the paramedics go without taking any further action such as phoning the police was ‘not very good practice and not professional’ but added that he was not blaming the paramedics, who he realised were just doing as they had been advised by ambulance control.
Coroner McGriskin said that police take notebook entries of incidents ‘for good reason’ and that in a society where they may be ‘called to court more and more’, that it ‘might be useful’ for the ambulance service to adopt a similar practice.
Professor Jack Crane, Acting State Pathologist and Professor of Forensic Medicine at Queen’s University, performed an autopsy on Mr Doherty’s body on March 24, 2016.
He found that Mr Doherty died of natural causes.
After a brief adjournment, Coroner McGriskin returned to deliver his findings.
He said that Mr Doherty had enjoyed good health but had drunk excessive amounts of alcohol some time before his death resulting in a fatty liver.
Coroner McGriskin added: “The purpose of an inquest is not to attribute blame or responsibility but more could have and should have been done to help this man.
“I can’t say if he had received treatment it would have produced a different outcome but, at the very least, he should have been conveyed to a hospital to receive that treatment.
“Assumptions were made about this man’s presentation and condition; it’s different looking back when everything is clear but, had it not been assumed that, in the words of ambulance control, that he was ‘just a drunk’ more could have been done.”