Flats complex planned for site of Earth nightclub gets green light from planners


Planning officials have recommended approving a proposal to demolish a landmark building in Derry and replace it with apartments – despite more than 200 objections from local residents.
The owners of the Earth complex at the junction of Strand Road and Rock Road last year applied for planning permission to knock the building down and build 23 apartments on the site.
However, the number of apartments proposed for the site was later reduced to 16.
Around 300 households in the area were consulted by Derry City and Strabane District Council’s planning department about the proposal.
A total of 202 objection were received by the council, with most objections being based on the fact that there was to be no parking provision with the new complex.
However, planning officials have recommended that the application be approved.
The final say on the matter now lies with the council’s planning committee which will meet next week.
The original application submitted last year involved the construction of 23 apartments on the site.
Fourteen of the apartments would have had one bedroom with the other nine having two bedrooms.
However, the proposed new 16 apartments will be made up of two and three-bedroom flats.
The demolition would incorporate both the Earth Nightclub and Cole’s Bar.
The owners of the site are Edenkeel Ltd.
Earth Nightclub was for many years one of Derry’s most popular nightspots, attracting hundreds of revellers each night it was open.
However, the nightclub has been closed for a number of years.
After details of the planning application for the Strand Road site were revealed by the Derry News last April, a large number of objections were received from local residents.
These included people living in surrounding streets such as Rock Road, Aberfoyle Crescent, Duncreggan Road, Dill Park and Baronet Street.
In a report on the proposed development, which has been submitted to the council’s planning committee, a planning office said that a total of 208 representations were received to the plans.
The officer said that many of the representations were ‘numerous letters from the same households’.
Among the concerns expressed by local residents, the officer said, was parking in the area and access to the apartment complex for the emergency services.
In their report, the officer said that all of the objections had been considered on the amended plans put forward for the site.
The report states: “Following the issues raised relating to parking, the agent submitted further correspondence comparing the parking requirements for the existing use as a public house versus a change to residential accommodation, based on the ‘Parking Standards’.
“Through this assessment, the agent demonstrated that the public house would require 214 spaces, whereas a change to residential would require approx. 25 spaces; therefore there is a net decrease of 189 parking spaces.
“In considering the issues with parking, there is currently no parking provision for the existing public house and night club, and no parking has been proposed for the apartment development.
“This site is however located within the Central Area and within the designated Flat Zone and it is recognised that parking for 25 spaces would be normally be required for 16 apartments.
“However, the public house would have required a substantial number of parking spaces to be provided in comparison to the apartment development.
“Planning officials therefore consider that given that the site is located within walking distance to the City Centre and to shopping facilities on Strand Road; it is located along a main transport corridor with bus routes; and space has been provided within the site for secure bicycle storage, that these factors are material in outweighing the need for 25 parking spaces to be provided.
“The issues raised by the objectors have been considered in detail; however, on balance it is considered that this redevelopment proposal is acceptable, and additionally it will bring the added benefit of regenerating this prominent site and will enhance the streetscape along Strand Road.”