Durkan demands HMRC ‘culture change’ to avoid 'hostility and suspicion'


SDLP Foyle MP Mark Durkan has called for a change of culture in HMRC so that there is no longer hostility and suspicion towards its customers who are claiming tax credits – not least in Derry and throughout the North.
Speaking during a House of Commons debate on Concentrix, Mr Durkan said: “This debacle happened in the context of a progressive rundown in the capacity and character of HMRC, which then led to it outsourcing bits of work. It is the nature of that work and outsourcing that really raises questions about the mentality in HMRC.
“In a written answer, the Minister confirmed this to me: ‘during the course of the contract, HMRC delegated a total caseload of 2,209,500 cases for high risk renewal checks by Concentrix.’
“It was HMRC itself that decided that more than two million cases could be appraised as high-risk renewals.
“When Concentrix received those cases, 1,635,676 of them were not the subject of further investigation for fraud or error, which means that it screened out 74% of the caseload that had been identified by HMRC.
“I ask Members to think about what we would have been dealing with if there had not been that screening.
“We would have had multiple versions of this problem – the adversity endured by our constituents; and the absurdity in the grievous conjecture that was being used against people.
“The high-risk cases referred to Concentrix were placed in three main risk categories, and those three categories were decided by, and designed by, HMRC, not by Concentrix.
“Many of us have had our own difficulties when dealing with HMRC about tax credits. Certainly in my constituency, I have had some particular issues in relation to the plight of cross-border workers, whose position is constantly mishandled by HMRC. At times, it seems that there is no end in sight to the difficulties.
“Let us remember that what drove the cut-off of tax credits for most people was the application of the compliance requirement of 30 days.
“Therefore, officials using the HMRC system and the HMRC standard that was contracted to Concentrix sent letters to people saying, ‘Unless you return information within 30 days, your benefit will be stopped.’
“Most of the stops were made because information was supposedly not received within 30 days. That is why many cases were overturned on mandatory reconsideration, because by that stage the information had been provided.
“I hope that the Minister will look at this again.
“She says that lessons will be learned. I hope that this will not be like Brexit means Brexit; “lessons will be learned” should mean that lessons will be learned.
“We hope that those lessons will be learned within HMRC itself, and that they will include looking at whether there has been particular misuse of provisions of the Tax Credits Act 2002.
Economic Secretary to the Treasury, Simon Kirby, replied: “I am happy to commit to look carefully at that matter and to get back to the hon. Gentleman.”