Woman whose arm was partially amputated loses £1m compensation claim
A woman whose arm was partially amputated after being injured in a fall has lost a £1m compensation claim over her treatment at Altnagelvin and the Causeway Hospital.
High Court judge Mr Justice O’Hara ruled on Friday that she had failed to establish any medical negligence against either the Northern or Western Health Trusts.
“The plaintiff was treated properly and in accordance with established good practice in both hospitals,” he held.
Now aged in her sixties, the woman suffered a fractured wrist after slipping and falling on a patch of ice at her home in January 2009.


She initially attended the Causeway Hospital in Coleraine and was put in a complete cast below the elbow.
Later that month she underwent surgery to have wires inserted at Altnagelvin Hospital in Derry.
A lighter cast was applied at that stage amid anticipations the fracture would fully heal without complications.
Instead, however, the woman developed a rare condition known as Complex Regional Pain Syndrome (CRPS).
Despite repeated efforts to resolve the problems, in June 2012 her right arm had to be amputated below the elbow.
Lawyers representing the woman sued both Trusts for alleged negligent treatment following the accident.
Based on expert evidence, they claimed the CRPS was probably caused by applying a closed cast, instead of one split to allow for any swelling, in the Causeway Hospital.
The alleged failing was made worse by the length of time it took for the woman to be seen and have the original plaster removed at Altnagelvin, it was contended.
Both defendants disputed her case, insisting the application of a complete cast was standard practice at the time and remains a recognised procedure today.
The so-called delay in further treatment at Altnagelvin was neither unusual or unreasonable, the court heard.
Despite acknowledging the tragic circumstances, the defendants insisted the woman’s treatment did not cause the CRPS which culminated in the loss of her arm.
With the claim for damages set at £1m, Mr Justice O’Hara had to determine if she had established any liability against the two Trusts.
“She is a lady whose life has been turned upside down following a nasty but otherwise innocuous injury,” the judge recognised.
“The question for me in this negligence case is whether she has been extraordinarily unlucky or whether she is the victim of poor medical treatment by either of the defendants.”
Ultimately he found her expert witness, a former orthopaedic surgeon, to have been unreliable and advanced propositions which lacked any evidential basis.
“I regard it as little short of outrageous for him to opine that CRPS had started by the time the plaintiff left Causeway,” he stated.
Backing the defendant’s case, Mr Justice O’Hara confirmed that the claim for damages is to be dismissed.
He added: “Even if I had found that there was some negligence at any level, I am not persuaded on the evidence in this case that a causal link has been established between any of the treatment which the plaintiff received and the onset of CRPS.”