CHARLIE FROM THE STANDS: How did this happen? How was it let happen?

A young child runs across the Brandywell pitch with a flare last week.placeholder image
A young child runs across the Brandywell pitch with a flare last week.

Oh, how it might have been so different…

You will have read recently about Ireland & UK winning the bid for EURO 2028, a big achievement for all entities involved and undoubtedly a moment of pride for each as well.placeholder image
You will have read recently about Ireland & UK winning the bid for EURO 2028, a big achievement for all entities involved and undoubtedly a moment of pride for each as well.

How did this happen? How was it let happen?

Imagine if the headline in Saturday’s newspapers was the above. Whilst flares may add to the atmosphere of a game, creating an aesthetic backdrop for hardcore fans to sing and chant which in turn motivates the players on the pitch – they also represent a huge risk. There is a reason UEFA has introduced legislation prohibiting the use of them. They are lethal, burning as hot as 1,600 °C, which in case you didn’t know, is hot enough to melt metal. So, imagine the damage it could do if it struck a head, a hand or flesh. It could be devastating.

So, when you see that kid running down the pitch holding it, you immediately think the worst.

If you think I am being dramatic, have a look at the numerous fans, stewards and players that have suffered injuries from flares. Look at some the examples: the football fan in Brazil that had his hand blown off; a goalkeeper that had his career ended when he went to kick a flare off the pitch; or the Scottish Cup Final where a fan lost three fingers. That's not to mention the numerous facial burns, eye injuries and burnt clothing reported throughout the LOI over the past few seasons - it is a pyrotechnic epidemic and it will end in tears if something isn't done.

There have been several questions around why nobody intervened, getting rid of it before it caused damage to the pitch. However, the UEFA directive is clear – no player, fan or steward is to go near a flare once lit. The oxidants in the flare will burn out to completion, so once it’s ignited, all you are meant to do is stand well back and let it extinguish. Which is exactly what the Derry City stewards were doing, before a child snatched it.

So, with directives in place and occurrences still happening, how does the FAI and the League address what is becoming a growing concern this season? Crowd-searching isn’t working (or perhaps not being implemented well enough). You have to bear in mind that these things are often as small as a can of 7Up, and can be smuggled in by minors who cannot be searched.

Clubs will aim to find solutions themselves – something which is becoming a recurring theme in the League when it comes to issues. In my opinion, the only solution is to work with and educate supporters through community engagement. By speaking with fans, exploring other ways of adding to the matchday experience, clubs can gain so much. However, like most new features or roles, it can cost money that clubs would rather use elsewhere. But let’s break it down…

For every flare incident, clubs are hit with fines, which cost – you guessed it – money. The more this happens, the bigger the chance of matches being played behind closed doors which would cost clubs – you guessed it again – money. By hiring a community liaison officer, even on a part time basis, clubs would be able to at least begin to address such issues and put in frameworks to prevent such fines. Put yourself in Philip O’Doherty’s position, he and the Derry City off-field staff are working tirelessly to ensure the club is competitive on the pitch and each and every fan has an enjoyable matchday experience, only for a small group to jeopardize everything. It’s not acceptable.

In contrast, look at the GAA and the Ulster Championship game at Celtic Park on Saturday past. 15,000 spectators took to the Lone Moor Road and there was not one incident. Derry City matches should be able to happen without the risk of fines or action for the mindless antics of ‘fans’, and I feel that by incorporating somebody responsible for specifically building relationships with communities could certainly play a part.

Speaking of the GAA and that wonderful Saturday afternoon, let’s talk about the genius of Jim McGuinness. It baffles me how people question this man's ability to get the job done, as he continues to deliver on the big stages. Jim’s re-entry to the management realms of the GAA comes after a less than successful stint in football.

Perhaps Jim being known as a GAA man stood against his chances of ever landing a Manager role in the League of Ireland, despite stepping into football way back in October 2014. He then dedicated 10 years of his life to learning, developing, and refining his football management skills with the likes of Celtic, Chinese Super League side Beijing Sinobo Guoan and Charlotte Independence in the USL Championship. But when it came down to home, I often wondered why a League of Ireland club didn't give him the opportunity to manage, or even become a No. 2.

For me, the perfect opportunity was when Finn Harps gave Dave Rogers a four-year deal in December 2022. I often wondered if had Jim McGuinness been given a four-year project with Finn Harps, would ‘Jimmy’s Winning Matches’ have been blasting around Finn Park on a Friday night? Unfortunately, we may never know, but one thing I am almost certain of, is the League has lost out on someone who all clubs could have learned a lot from.

It is people like Jim that the League and the FAI need to begin welcoming into in the ecosystem, high-performing people from other industries, as it is pretty evident that the growth mindset being adopted by some has yet to become unanimous. More on that another day!

----

The title race is heating up nicely as we hit the third-way point, and we are beginning to see how difficult it will be for Shamrock Rovers to be displaced as Champions of Ireland.

For the opening 50 minutes last Friday night, we seen essentially the two best teams in the country going at it hammer and tong, in a spectacle which fans want to see. Then within 10 minutes, Shamrock Rovers scored three goals, taking the game away from Derry completely. Derry then emulated this on Monday night against St Pat’s in a five-minute spell. The pleasing thing for me was the Derry City aggression on Monday, with the players’ bite evident from the start. Not that it is something to praise as such, but in the opening stages, five Pat’s players needed medical attention as a result of Derry challenges. And as sure as snow is white, it was Patrick Hoban setting the tempo with a yellow card after just 13 minutes.

I mentioned on RTE on Friday night, that Derry needed to show more fight, more aggression and more desire to go that extra mile to win games because rest assured Shamrock Rovers are not handing their title to anyone. It has to be fought from them. It undoubtedly will be difficult and going to the well three days after a huge home match against your bitter rivals isn’t easy, but Derry showed on Monday they are up for a long slog and that’s what the season will be.

Indeed, Rovers’ draw with Shelbourne on Monday night was a result that suited the rest of the chasing pack. Damien Duff’s tirade towards his player Shane Farrell for getting sent-off shortly after coming on, exemplifies the standards that Duff is expecting of his team this season, and on the pitch, they matched Rovers all over. I honestly believe that the criticism of Farrell is coming from a good place, and that Duff just wants him to learn and learn faster, but calling your players out after the game as a collective is fine, which Damien did the week before. However, signaling out a player as harshly as he did with Farrell was borderline and I don't think we will hear the end of this.

The other games were as predicted uneventful, although I have to mention that Bohemians are now the in-form team in the league with four wins from five. Could they push themselves into contention? Let’s see.

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice