£1.2bn of City and Growth Deal funding remains unspent, says report

Coronavirus – Fri Jan 8, 2020placeholder image
Coronavirus – Fri Jan 8, 2020

The Audit Office report has warned that significant investment is ‘potentially at risk if the pace of delivery does not accelerate’

About £1.2 billion of Government funding for City and Growth Deals in Northern Ireland remains unspent, an Audit Office report has found.

The report has warned that significant investment is “potentially at risk if the pace of delivery does not accelerate”.

Northern Ireland’s Comptroller and Auditor General, Dorinnia Carville’s report said the real-terms value of the available funding reduces by “approximately £37 million for each year of delay”.

A spokesperson for the Department of Finance said it remains confident that the objectives of the deals will be delivered.

The auditor’s report examines how funds for the £1.3 billion deals have been utilised to date, and how efficiently and effectively projects have progressed since the first deal was announced in 2018.

The City and Growth Deals bring together the UK Government, Northern Ireland Executive, local government, and a range of other partners to deliver investment aimed at transforming the region’s economy and regenerating communities.

placeholder image

The four deals are the Belfast Region City Deal, the Derry and Strabane District Council City Deal, the Causeway Coast and Glens Growth Deal, and the Mid South West Growth Deal.

The auditor said while there is “evidence of constructive and evolving collaboration across the Deals, overall progress has been slower than originally anticipated”.

The £1.3 billion funding package includes £562 million each from Stormont and Westminster.

The deals are intended to be delivered over a 15-year timeframe from formal signing.

The report said: “Since the launch of the first Deal, Belfast Region City Deal, in 2018, overall progress has been slower than originally anticipated.

“By March 2025, less than 5% of total NI Executive and UK Government capital funding (£58 million) had been utilised across the Deals.

“By March 2026, utilisation is forecast to reach approximately 8%.”

The report said “only a small number of projects have reached operational stage to date” and they are all within the Belfast deal.

It added: “Delays have contributed to funding pressures, cost escalation and the erosion of the real value of the fixed funding envelope.

“At March 2026, approximately £1.2 billion of Central Government funding remained unspent – assuming a 3% annual inflation rate, the real-terms value of this funding reduces by approximately £37 million for each year of delay.

“These factors point to the need for the pace of Deal delivery to be accelerated in order to maximise the benefit to Northern Ireland.

“We also found that the timeframe around potential availability of Deal funding is not currently recognised and formally managed as a strategic risk across Deal Risk Registers, despite a potential risk to funding if delivery does not accelerate.”

The report said the deals have the potential to bring major benefits to Northern Ireland, but only if “decisive action is taken to accelerate delivery and ensure value for money”.

It added: “The Deals have secured a substantial net funding gain for Northern Ireland and demonstrate the potential benefits of co-ordinated investment between Central and Local Government and other partners.

“However, at this stage of delivery, overall value for money cannot yet be demonstrated.

“Progress has been slow; funding utilisation remains low; delays continue to erode the real value of the available investment; and weaknesses in governance maturity and cost capture limit transparency and accountability.

“Without decisive action to address these issues, there is a risk that the Deals will not maximise the benefits of the significant public investment committed over their remaining lifetimes.”

Ms Carville said: “City and Growth Deals represent a positive example of collaboration between central and local government, and I warmly welcome the evidence of constructive engagement noted in today’s report.

“At the same time, progress remains slow, with much of the available funds remaining unutilised. Continued delays are eroding the value of this potentially transformative investment.”

“With only a small number of projects operational, it is not yet possible to provide a proper assessment of long-term outcomes.

“However, there are already weaknesses in arrangements for capturing costs and ensuring value for money.

“Without decisive action to address these issues, there is a risk that potential benefits will not be maximised.

“Given the significant public investment committed, my office will continue to closely monitor both the ongoing delivery of City and Growth Deals, and the action taken in response to the recommendations made in today’s report.”

A spokesperson for the Department of Finance said: “The department notes the publication of the Audit Office’s report on City and Growth Deals and welcomes its recognition of the constructive collaboration between central and local government.

“The department will consider the report’s recommendations.

“City and Growth Deals are designed as long-term programmes of investment with projects being delivered over 10–15 years.

“As delivery of projects progress, the deals will drive economic growth (and) create more and better employment opportunities.

“The department remains confident these objectives are, and will be, delivered on.

A UK Government spokesperson said it is investing £617 million through the four City and Growth Deals “helping to deliver on the Government’s economic growth mission across the whole of the UK”.

The spokesperson added: “In April, the most recent of these moved from planning to delivery with the formal signing of the Causeway Coast and Glens Growth Deal.

“Whilst delivery sits with the Executive and local councils, the UK Government remains in close communication with partners and is committed to ensuring the benefits of this significant investment in the City Deals are felt as soon as possible, boosting prosperity and growth across all of Northern Ireland.”

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice